More stocks to consider
Alternative stocks to Amerisafe (NasdaqGS:AMSF)


These are the alternatives to Amerisafe that fall within the same industry, Property & Casualty Insurance, or region, USA.

How to read the ranks

For every stock, we judge its performance against its peers and rank it on a scale of 1 to 100. The higher the rank, the better the stock performs than its peers. And, we do this for six investment strategies:

Value - shows how good of a value the stock is. Green is "inexpensive"; red is "expensive".

Growth - shows a company's growth potential. Green is "high growth" expected; red is "tough times ahead".

Safety - relates to the amount of debt a company has. Green is low debt level; red is high debt level.

Combined Financial - this isn't an average of the first three ranks but rather a consolidated view across several financial indicators. Green = good; red = tread carefully.

(NEW) Sentiment - quantifies professional analyst ratings and holdings as well as market pulse. Green = positive sentiment; red = skepticism (Only available to Premium Subscribers).

(NEW) 360° View - the ultimate rating with all financial and non-financial indicators.

See Amerisafe Performance

Amerisafe stock research in summary

amerisafe.com


Amerisafe shares are more expensive than other comparable stocks. While they are safely financed, they are poor value, and show below average growth. We recommend evaluating whether the future of the company Amerisafe is really as positive as the high price of the shares suggests. If you come to the conclusion that the future for this company is only average, that could be a reason to sell this share.


Latest Obermatt Ranks


Log in or sign up to see the new 360° View and Sentiment ranks.

Country USA
Industry Property & Casualty Insurance
Index
Size class Medium

Large companies - similar industry as Amerisafe

Similar Stocks VALUEVVV GROWTHVV SAFETYVV COMBINED
1. CNAF (XXL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
1. CNAF (XXL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 35 23 75 96
2. Hanover Insurance Group (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
2. Hanover Insurance Group (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 83 89 86 96
3. Allstate (XXL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
3. Allstate (XXL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 57 79 75 84
4. Travelers (XXL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
4. Travelers (XXL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 41 33 70 81
5. Progressive (XXL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
5. Progressive (XXL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 19 97 77 79
6. Selective Insurance (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
6. Selective Insurance (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 75 43 86 72
7. Erie Indemnity (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
7. Erie Indemnity (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 9 61 52 62
8. Old Republic (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
8. Old Republic (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 77 39 65 55
9. Mercury General (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
9. Mercury General (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 31 55 98 50
10. Fidelity National Financial (XL, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
10. Fidelity National Financial (XL, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 67 93 49 47

July 10, 2025

Why popular stocks have low ratings

It’s easier said than done. When your stock drops, it’s easy to want to sell it and find a better performer. Think twice, or even three times, before trading. Those fees (especially the hidden ones) can eat up your gains.

Large companies - similar region as Amerisafe

Similar Stocks VALUEVVV GROWTHVV SAFETYVV COMBINED
1. PriceSmart (XL, US)  Hypermarkets, Super Centers
1. PriceSmart (XL, US)   Hypermarkets, Super Centers 83 58 91 100
2. Nexteer Automotive Group (XL, US)  Auto Parts & Equipment
2. Nexteer Automotive Group (XL, US)   Auto Parts & Equipment 81 99 98 100
3. Hewlett Packard Enterprise (XXL, US)  Technology Hardware & Peripherals
3. Hewlett Packard Enterprise (XXL, US)   Technology Hardware & Peripherals 93 75 76 100
4. Voya Financial (XL, US)  Other Financial Services
4. Voya Financial (XL, US)   Other Financial Services 93 27 67 100
5. Cognizant Technology (XXL, US)  IT Consulting & oth. Services
5. Cognizant Technology (XXL, US)   IT Consulting & oth. Services 96 48 95 100
6. Synchrony Financial (XXL, US)  Consumer Finance
6. Synchrony Financial (XXL, US)   Consumer Finance 75 59 94 100
7. First Republic Bank (XL, US)  Regional Banks
7. First Republic Bank (XL, US)   Regional Banks 99 55 97 100
8. Universal Health Services (XXL, US)  Health Care Facilities
8. Universal Health Services (XXL, US)   Health Care Facilities 82 56 88 100
9. Cheesecake Factory (XL, US)  Restaurants
9. Cheesecake Factory (XL, US)   Restaurants 76 91 88 100
10. Hub Group (XL, US)  Air Freight & Logistics
10. Hub Group (XL, US)   Air Freight & Logistics 86 67 96 100

July 10, 2025


Find more stock ideas
Use your own criteria to filter for stocks or sign up for the latest Top 10 Stock tips.
Log in or Sign up

Mid sized companies - similar industry as Amerisafe

Similar Stocks VALUEVVV GROWTHVV SAFETYVV COMBINED
1. RLI (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
1. RLI (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 11 17 98 98
2. Palomar Holdings (M, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
2. Palomar Holdings (M, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 15 100 100 93
3. United Fire (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
3. United Fire (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 95 77 67 86
4. Employers (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
4. Employers (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 65 3 79 79
5. Root (M, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
5. Root (M, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 7 81 58 76
6. Stewart Information (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
6. Stewart Information (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 79 53 79 74
7. Kinsale Capital Group (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
7. Kinsale Capital Group (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 1 99 46 58
8. ProAssurance (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
8. ProAssurance (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 55 23 86 52
9. Safety Insurance (L, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
9. Safety Insurance (L, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 85 53 37 21
10. Lemonade (M, US)  Property & Casualty Insurance
10. Lemonade (M, US)   Property & Casualty Insurance 7 75 11 16

July 10, 2025


Mid sized companies - similar region as Amerisafe

Similar Stocks VALUEVVV GROWTHVV SAFETYVV COMBINED
1. Cal-Maine Foods (L, US)  Packaged Foods & Meats
1. Cal-Maine Foods (L, US)   Packaged Foods & Meats 70 91 100 100
2. ALLETE (L, US)  Electric Utilities
2. ALLETE (L, US)   Electric Utilities 77 91 82 100
3. Taboola.com (L, US)  Interactive Media & Services
3. Taboola.com (L, US)   Interactive Media & Services 91 29 81 100
4. Perella Weinberg (M, US)  Investment Banking & Brokerage
4. Perella Weinberg (M, US)   Investment Banking & Brokerage 81 77 58 100
5. Provident Services (M, US)  Thrifts & Mortgage Finance
5. Provident Services (M, US)   Thrifts & Mortgage Finance 73 99 75 100
6. Federated Investors (L, US)  Asset Management & Custody
6. Federated Investors (L, US)   Asset Management & Custody 78 84 91 100
7. Standex (M, US)  Industrial Machinery
7. Standex (M, US)   Industrial Machinery 64 86 90 100
8. Avanos Medical (M, US)  Health Care Supplies
8. Avanos Medical (M, US)   Health Care Supplies 96 29 95 100
9. Quanex Building Products (L, US)  Building Products
9. Quanex Building Products (L, US)   Building Products 93 75 72 100
10. Valley National Bancorp (L, US)  Regional Banks
10. Valley National Bancorp (L, US)   Regional Banks 100 100 59 100

July 10, 2025



Obermatt Portfolio Performance
We’re so convinced about our research, that we buy our stock tips.
See the performance of the Obermatt portfolio.